The Power of Shared Experience and Belonging

How connecting with others may support recovery from PTSD, and what the research tells us about the benefits and limitations of group-based therapy.

When trauma leaves us feeling alone

Trauma can change how we see ourselves, how we relate to other people and how safe we feel in the world. For some people, the aftermath of trauma involves intrusive memories, anxiety, hypervigilance, difficulties with trust or a persistent feeling of being on guard. Others may withdraw from relationships, struggle to explain what they have experienced or feel that nobody could truly understand.

Sometimes, the loneliness that follows trauma can be almost as difficult as the original experience. A person may be surrounded by other people and still feel profoundly alone. This raises an important question: could connecting with others who have experienced trauma help us recover?

Group-based psychological interventions offer one possible way of supporting people experiencing post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). They provide opportunities to work through difficulties alongside others, with the guidance of a trained therapist or facilitator. But what does the research tell us about their effectiveness? Does sharing experiences help people feel less alone? Is group therapy right for everyone?

A recent systematic review by Whelan and colleagues (2026) offers some useful insights into these questions. Their research examined the effectiveness of group-based interventions for PTSD and explored whether factors such as shared experiences, group membership and belonging might influence outcomes. The findings are encouraging, but they also remind us that recovery is personal and that there is no single therapeutic approach that will suit everyone.

What did the research find?

Whelan et al. (2026) reviewed 40 studies involving 8,504 participants across 11 countries. The studies examined different types of group-based psychological interventions for PTSD. Overall, the researchers found that people receiving group-based interventions experienced meaningful reductions in PTSD symptoms compared with the relevant comparison groups. This is encouraging evidence that group therapy can be helpful for people experiencing the effects of trauma.

However, there is an important distinction to make. When group-based interventions were compared with waiting lists or minimal support, the benefits were clearer. When researchers compared group treatment with other active treatments, including similar therapy delivered individually, the differences were less conclusive. In other words, group therapy can help, but the research does not establish that it is better than individual therapy.
This matters because it allows us to recognise the value of group work without presenting it as the right choice for everyone.

The review also explored whether the type of therapy, the experiences of group members and the size or composition of groups might influence outcomes. Some differences were observed, but further research is needed before firm conclusions can be drawn.
One particularly interesting aspect of the research concerns something that can be difficult to measure: the experience of belonging.

Why might being with others help after trauma?

Trauma can affect our sense of connection with other people.
When something frightening, overwhelming or deeply distressing happens, our understanding of safety and trust may change. We might become more cautious about relationships, question other people’s intentions or feel that we need to manage everything ourselves.
For people who have experienced interpersonal trauma, such as abuse or violence, these difficulties may be particularly significant. When another person has caused harm, learning to feel safe with other people again can be complicated.

A well-facilitated therapeutic group may offer an opportunity to experience connection in a different way. Here are some of the ways this might help:

1. Discovering that we are not alone

One of the most difficult aspects of trauma can be the feeling that nobody else could understand. People may worry that others will judge them, question their reactions or struggle to comprehend why certain experiences continue to affect them.

Within a suitable therapeutic group, hearing someone else describe familiar feelings or difficulties may bring a sense of recognition. A person might think, I recognise that feeling. I thought I was the only one who experienced it. This does not mean that everyone’s experiences are the same. Two people can go through very different events and have very different responses.

However, recognising similarities in the emotional impact of trauma can help people feel less isolated. It can also create opportunities to speak about experiences that may previously have felt too difficult, shameful or confusing to share.

2. Challenging shame and self-blame

Shame can be a powerful part of the aftermath of trauma. People may question their own reactions, blame themselves for what happened or believe that their difficulties mean there is something wrong with them. These feelings can be reinforced when someone feels unable to talk openly about their experiences.

A supportive group may offer a different perspective. Listening to others discuss similar fears, reactions or struggles can help people recognise that their responses are understandable in the context of what they have experienced. It may also provide opportunities to receive empathy rather than criticism.

This does not mean shame automatically disappears when people join a group. Some may initially feel uncomfortable, exposed or worried about being judged. The value lies in the possibility of experiencing a different kind of response from other people, within an environment where respect and boundaries are taken seriously.

3. Rebuilding trust in relationships

When trauma involves betrayal, exploitation or harm caused by another person, trusting others again can be difficult. Someone may want connection while simultaneously feeling frightened of becoming vulnerable. They may find themselves watching for signs of danger, withdrawing when relationships become closer or struggling to believe that other people have good intentions.

A therapeutic group cannot undo what has happened. However, a carefully managed group may offer opportunities to experience relationships in which people listen, respect boundaries and respond with consideration. Over time, these experiences may help some participants explore their expectations of others and develop greater confidence in relationships.

This is not about learning to trust everybody or ignoring warning signs. Healthy trust involves discernment, boundaries and the freedom to decide who feels safe enough to let into our lives. Nor should a group be assumed to be safe simply because it is therapeutic. The behaviour of the facilitator, the group’s boundaries and the way difficulties are handled, all matter.

4. Finding a sense of belonging

The researchers were particularly interested in the role that group membership might play in recovery. In everyday language, this is about belonging: feeling accepted, understood or connected to something beyond ourselves.
Research into social identity suggests that the groups we belong to can influence our wellbeing. Supportive group memberships may provide encouragement, shared understanding and a sense of connection during difficult periods.

Trauma can disrupt these connections. People may withdraw from friends and family, lose confidence in social situations or feel disconnected from communities that once mattered to them. A therapeutic group may offer an opportunity to develop a new sense of connection.

Importantly, belonging does not require everyone to have experienced exactly the same thing. Sometimes people connect through shared experiences. At other times, they connect through the feelings, challenges or hopes they have in common. The aim is not to make everyone the same. It is to create space for people to feel that their experiences matter and that they can be accepted without having to hide parts of themselves.

However, there is an important qualification here. Although belonging is a plausible explanation for why group therapy may help, Whelan and colleagues found that very few studies had directly measured group processes such as belonging, trust and cohesion. We therefore cannot conclude that belonging itself caused the improvements in PTSD symptoms, so it remains an important question for future research.

Does it matter whether people have experienced similar trauma?

It might seem logical that a group of people who have experienced similar events would be more helpful than a group whose members have different histories. There can be value in shared experience. People may recognise aspects of one another’s struggles without needing lengthy explanations. For someone who has experienced a particular form of trauma, meeting others who have faced something similar may reduce the feeling of being different or misunderstood.

However, similar experiences do not automatically mean similar needs.

Two people who have experienced the same type of trauma may understand it very differently. Their circumstances, previous experiences, relationships, cultural backgrounds and ways of coping may all influence how they make sense of what happened. Equally, people who have experienced different forms of trauma may recognise common feelings of fear, shame, mistrust or disconnection.

The review explored whether the type of trauma experienced and the composition of a group influenced outcomes. Some patterns suggested that groups with shared trauma experiences, women-only groups and larger groups had more favourable results in certain comparisons. These findings are interesting, but they are not definitive. The available evidence does not establish that one particular group composition is best for everyone. It would therefore be unhelpful to assume that people must have experienced the same type of trauma to benefit from working together.

What matters is whether the group provides a suitable therapeutic environment for the people involved, with appropriate attention to their needs, preferences and circumstances.

When group therapy might feel difficult

Although group therapy can offer opportunities for connection, it is important to recognise that being in a group can also feel challenging. For someone who has experienced trauma, talking in front of others may feel exposing. They may worry about being judged, feel uncomfortable hearing about other people’s experiences or find themselves comparing their trauma with that of other group members. Someone might wonder whether their own experience was serious enough to justify their feelings. Another person might feel overwhelmed by hearing details that remind them of something they have experienced.

These reactions do not mean that group therapy is necessarily unsuitable. They do, however, highlight the importance of thoughtful preparation and sensitive facilitation. A trauma-informed group should have clear boundaries and expectations. Participants should understand how confidentiality will be approached, what participation involves and what support is available if they become distressed. Nobody should be pressured to disclose personal details or recount traumatic experiences simply to demonstrate that they are engaging with therapy.

People also need room to make choices. For some, group work may feel appropriate from the outset. Others may prefer individual therapy, at least initially, or find that a combination of individual and group support best meets their needs. There is no need to interpret a preference for individual therapy as a failure to engage or an unwillingness to recover.

The aim is to find an approach that supports the individual, not to expect the individual to fit a particular approach.

The review also highlighted an important limitation: adverse effects were not consistently reported across the studies. We therefore know less than we should about how frequently people experience unwanted effects or difficulties during group treatment. This is an area where more careful research and reporting would be needed.

What does this mean for trauma-informed practice?

For professionals working with trauma, the research offers an opportunity to reflect on how psychological support is provided.
It suggests that group-based interventions deserve serious consideration as a way of helping people experiencing PTSD. At the same time, it reinforces the importance of individual needs and preferences when deciding which form of treatment may be appropriate.

Several considerations stand out for me:

Connection can be valuable, but it cannot be forced. A group may provide opportunities for belonging and shared understanding, but these experiences need time and the right conditions to develop.

Shared experiences can help, but differences matter too. People should not be expected to respond in the same way simply because they have experienced similar events.

Psychological safety needs active attention. Clear boundaries, respectful communication and sensitive facilitation are important parts of creating an environment where people can participate meaningfully.

Group therapy is one option, not a universal solution. The evidence does not establish that group treatment is better than individual therapy for everyone with PTSD. The suitability of an intervention needs to be considered in relation to the person receiving it.

These principles also apply beyond formal group therapy. They are relevant to peer support, community-based services and other settings in which people come together to talk about difficult experiences.

However, it is important to distinguish these settings. A professionally delivered group psychological intervention is not the same as an informal support group, even though both may offer opportunities for connection.

What are the limitations of the research?

The findings from Whelan and colleagues are encouraging, but they need to be understood in context.

The researchers brought together studies involving different therapies, populations and traumatic experiences. This means that the results cannot tell us exactly how every type of group intervention will work for every person.

Many of the studies had methodological limitations, and the authors identified possible publication bias. In simple terms, research showing positive results may be more likely to be published than research showing less encouraging findings.

The evidence base included a substantial number of studies involving combat-related PTSD, with most research conducted in the United States. Further research is needed to understand how well the findings apply to people from different backgrounds and circumstances.

Perhaps the most important limitation concerns the question of belonging.
Although many studies discussed the potential importance of group processes, only two explicitly measured these factors. The researchers could not establish whether feeling connected to a group, identifying with other members or experiencing greater trust actually explained the improvements observed.
This is an important gap because it leaves us with two related but different questions:

  • Does group-based treatment help reduce PTSD symptoms?
  • If it does, what aspects of the group experience contribute to that improvement?

The review provides encouraging evidence in relation to the first question. The second remains less well understood.

Future research could explore these processes directly, including how people experience group membership, what makes a group feel supportive and whether these experiences are associated with better outcomes.

Recovery is about more than feeling less distressed

When we talk about recovery from trauma, it is easy to focus only on symptoms.
Reducing intrusive memories, anxiety, avoidance and hypervigilance can be an important part of treatment. But people may also want to rebuild relationships, feel more confident in their decisions, regain a sense of identity or reconnect with activities and communities that matter to them.
For some, being able to speak openly with another person may represent meaningful progress. For others, recovery may involve learning to recognise their needs, establish boundaries or feel safer in everyday situations.

Group therapy may support some of these developments, but we should not assume that they will occur simply because someone attends a group. Nor should we suggest that social connection alone is sufficient treatment for PTSD. It is helpful to recognise that recovery can involve several dimensions of well-being. Symptom reduction matters, but so can a person’s sense of connection, autonomy and ability to participate in life in ways that feel meaningful to them.

The research raises useful questions about how psychological services could better understand and support these wider aspects of recovery.

Overall reflection: the importance of feeling understood

Whelan and colleagues’ (2026) review provides encouraging evidence that group-based psychological interventions can help reduce PTSD symptoms, and invites us to think about something that can be difficult to capture in research: the experience of being understood by another person.

After trauma, people may feel isolated, different or uncertain about whether they can trust others. A suitable therapeutic group may offer opportunities to recognise shared experiences, question self-blame and develop a sense of connection. But shared experience does not guarantee understanding, and belonging cannot be assumed. A group needs to be appropriate for its members, thoughtfully facilitated and responsive to individual differences.

The research reminds us that we still have much to learn about why group interventions help, who benefits most and how group relationships influence therapeutic outcomes. For trauma-informed practice, this is an important distinction. We can recognise the potential value of connection without assuming that every person needs the same kind of support.

Sometimes recovery involves learning to feel safer within ourselves. Sometimes it involves rebuilding trust with another person. And sometimes, finding ourselves in the company of people who understand aspects of our experience can help us feel a little less alone.

The challenge for those in psychological practice is to create opportunities for these experiences while respecting each person’s needs, boundaries and choices.


References

Whelan, É., Griffin, S. M., Ahern, E., Lebedová, A., McMahon, G., Bradshaw, D., & Muldoon, O. T. (2026). Group-Based Interventions for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Role of Trauma Type. Campbell Systematic Reviews, 22(3). https://doi.org/10.1177/18911803261471160

Read the original research: Group-Based Interventions for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder — full open-access article

This article offers an accessible discussion of published research. It is intended for information and reflection and does not replace the original research, professional clinical guidance or individualised assessment.

About the author

Lisa Harris
Psychotherapist | Clinical Supervisor | Consultant | Qualified Traumatologist

Lisa Harris is an online psychotherapist, clinical supervisor and consultant with extensive experience of working with adults particularly. Her professional interests include trauma, PTSD and CPTSD, neurodivergence, emotional regulation and trauma-informed practice.

Website: lisaharris.uk


Discover more from Lisa Harris

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *